Explore This Issue
November 2026“Highland Physician Sentenced to 97 Months in Prison” after billing for thousands of balloon sinuplasty procedures that she did not perform—U.S. Attorney’s Office, Northern District of Indiana, February 18, 2026 (Justice.gov. https://tinyurl.com/yc2bmbn7)
“Court Upholds North Carolina Physician’s Conviction for $46M Fraud Scheme” in which otolaryngologist reused single-use surgical devices on more than 1,500 Medicare patients—Becker’s ASC Review, January 27, 2025 (Becker’s ACS Review. https://tinyurl.com/4zxrwhy9)
Otolaryngology “Physicians group in El Paso accused of ‘upcoding’ to pay $750K settlement agreement”—KFox 14, June 23, 2021 (KFox 14. https://tinyurl.com/yjyzsvkb. Justice.gov. https://tinyurl.com/zj89w3zh)
And like most physicians, you were probably appalled by the unethical behavior of a few otolaryngologists whose actions raise scrutiny for the entire profession. Like most physicians, you’re far more likely to deal with the downstream consequences of medical fraud—including increased payer oversight, regulation, and prior authorization—than you are to encounter fraud personally. You’re more likely to tsk at the headlines than to talk publicly about medical fraud in otolaryngology and assume fraud isn’t something you need to worry about.
Fraud Is Rare. Scrutiny Is Not.
The federal government defines healthcare fraud as “the act of knowingly and willfully executing or attempting to execute a scheme or artifice to defraud any healthcare benefit program, or to obtain by false or fraudulent means any of the money or property owned by, or under the custody or control of, any health care benefits program.”
It can include willful misdiagnosis, medically unnecessary treatment, billing for services not performed, upcoding or unbundling procedures, altering documentation to support a claim, or kickbacks. It’s impossible to determine the true prevalence of healthcare fraud— in otolaryngology, any other medical specialty, or medicine at large—because fraud, almost by definition, usually occurs in the shadows.
The government, however, has aimed a spotlight at medical fraud. The Centers for Medicaid and Medicare Services (CMS) says that “waste in healthcare” represents up to 25% of healthcare spending in the U.S., with Medicare spending more than $5.5 billion in 2022 on “unnecessary or inappropriate services with little to no clinical benefit” (CMS.gov. https://tinyurl.com/5xfaffzn).
In September 2026, the U.S. Department of the Treasury announced that the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) had uncovered $17.5 billion in “suspected health care fraud,” and both the Treasury and White House Task Force to Eliminate Fraud are encouraging whistleblowers to report their concerns (U.S. Department of the Treasury. https://tinyurl.com/mry6nrwp).
Earlier this year, the U.S. Department of Justice launched the Fraud Oversight through Careful Use of Statistics (FOCUS) initiative—which seeks to enlist sophisticated civilian data miners to analyze publicly available government data for patterns that may indicate fraud (Crowell. https://tinyurl.com/5c2m5dvm). And CMS’s Wasteful and Inappropriate Service Reduction (WISeR) model, which uses technology-enabled prior authorization processes to determine coverage for selected nonemergent services (including hypoglossal nerve stimulation for obstructive sleep apnea) that may be “low value” or “prone to fraud and abuse,” is currently active in six states, with mandatory participation for all clinicians (JAMA. doi:10.1001/jama.2025.16326).
This increased scrutiny—from the government, from payers, and even from civilians—affects all physicians and patients.
“The government now is using data analytics to detect irregular billing patterns and to quantify and assess overpayments or damages,” said Carrie Valiant, JD, a Washington D.C.-based attorney with Epstein Becker Green. “We’re in the brave new world when it comes to detecting and enforcing fraud.”
Practice Patterns May Raise Questions
Delineating between “fraud” and “appropriate practice” isn’t necessarily as clear-cut as it may seem (ENTtoday. https://tinyurl.com/5e7pz5kc).
“A lot of ‘fraud’ may be inadvertent billing errors,” said Bruce Scott, MD, president of Kentuckiana Ear, Nose & Throat in Louisville, Ky., and former president of the American Medical Association, noting that medical billing has become extremely complex. The development and implementation of medical innovations add another layer of complexity, and there is sometimes confusion about how to best use (and charge for) technological advances. Overutilization of one technology or treatment can trigger scrutiny that extends well beyond that procedure. Balloon dilation of the sinuses, for example, “has good use in a variety of circumstances,” said Peter Manes, MD, associate professor of surgery (otolaryngology) at Yale School of Medicine in New Haven, Conn. But because the procedure can be financially lucrative, it has occasionally been overutilized. That overuse has drawn attention not only to balloon dilation, but also to endoscopic sinus surgery and other, unrelated ENT technologies, Dr. Manes said.
Prior authorization is one tool payers use to control utilization and deter fraud.
“It’s not a tool without merit,” said Vinay Rathi, MD, an assistant professor of otolaryngology and health policy researcher at the Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center in West Campus, Ohio, “but I think it ends up broadly making life a bit more difficult for everyone when, in reality, a lot of inappropriate use may be driven by a small group of outliers who may need some additional education on standard practice or how to select patients.”
Physicians and patients alike express frustration with prior authorization requirements. Otolaryngology offices currently complete an average of over 40 prior authorizations each week, according to the AAO-HNS (AAO-HNS. https://tinyurl.com/y62kvfck), and evidence suggests that prior authorization can lead to delays in care. Ninety-five percent of physicians surveyed by the American Medical Association in 2025 said prior authorization delays access to necessary care; 79% reported patient abandonment of treatment due to issues with prior authorization (AMA-ASSN.org. https://tinyurl.com/za5dev7n).
A 2021 review of more than 10,000 pediatric tonsillectomy claims found that implementation of prior authorization was associated with an immediate 2.38-day increase in time from consultation to surgery; tonsillectomy use did not significantly decline, and only 1.5% of claims were denied (Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. doi:10.1177/0194599820969631).
Increasingly, payers—and those interested in detecting fraud—are using artificial intelligence to analyze claims and treatment patterns. Physicians worry that AI oversight will increase denial rates (AMA-ASSN.org. https://tinyurl.com/za5dev7n); lawyers who specialize in healthcare litigation say they expect AI-driven oversight to accelerate enforcement, as the Department of Justice, Office of the Inspector General, and CMS are all rapidly scaling machine learning tools to flag irregularities (Arnall Golden Gregory LLP. https://tinyurl.com/yp6c8zcd).
Compliance Is the Best Defense
Good medical practice—and good compliance practices—is the best defense against possible allegations of fraud, inappropriate treatment, or irregular billing. Ethical practice is also the best way to protect your patients’ health, safeguard your own reputation and integrity, and preserve trust in the profession.
“Society expects us to police ourselves,” said G. Richard Holt, MD, MSE, MPH, MABE, MSAM, D Bioethics, professor emeritus of otolaryngology–head and neck surgery at the University of Texas San Antonio School of Medicine. “Patient welfare is the leading obligation we have, and ‘welfare’ includes everything from whether the patient was treated appropriately to whether they experienced significant health or financial losses because of our treatment.”
Physicians, Dr. Holt said, should also apply the ethical principles of autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence, and social justice to their practices. And if physicians encounter situations that appear to fall short of current clinical, ethical, and professional practice, they should get curious. Don’t assume malfeasance, but don’t sweep your concerns under the proverbial rug either. For practical guidance on how to evaluate and respond to a concern, see “From Red Flag to Responsible Response” below. Preventing problems begins with knowing and following all appropriate regulations and clinical guidelines. Although it can be challenging to keep up with the changing requirements of various payor policies, taking the time to familiarize yourself with their requirements (and looking them up when you’re unsure) can save you and your patients time—and headaches—in the long run.
If you’re not sure how to bill for a particular procedure, check with your colleagues and consult the American Academy of Otolaryngology for guidance. Do not rely solely on advice from fellow physicians or from manufacturer representatives. Some advice to maximize revenue may be ethically murky or inaccurate.
“If it seems like easy money, or seems too good to be true, it probably is,” said Ms. Valiant, the D.C.-based attorney who’s worked in healthcare litigation for more than 30 years. “You have to do your due diligence.”
Regularly compare your practice and billing patterns with industry norms. If you identify significant variations, investigate the reasons and document any clinical or operational factors that explain them. Be thorough.
“Don’t take a narrow approach to documentation. If your diagnosis or treatment plan is based, even in part, on a test that was done elsewhere, or you’re relying on previous provider records to demonstrate they did medical management first, make sure that shows up in your record,” Ms. Valiant advised.
If you’re part of a larger medical practice, routinely meet with your colleagues to review care patterns and billing. Monitor billing and collections for unusual activity or spikes. If you identify a billing discrepancy or error, don’t hide it. Work to refund or self-disclose the error, Ms. Valiant said.
A cautious, precise approach to medical billing will serve you well. Payers and regulators watch for “red flags” that can—but do not always—indicate possible fraud. These include routinely coding evaluation and management visits as Level 4 or 5, frequent use of modifiers, and unbundling of regularly bundled procedures (Khurana Law Firm. https://tinyurl.com/2ny7n5dp). (Note: If you don’t know how your billing department is coding your appointments and procedures, it’s time to find out.)
Investigate new treatments and technology carefully before adopting them. “Use your professional judgement,” Dr. Scott said. “Ask yourself, ‘Is this new innovation legit? Is this recommended billing legit?”
Maintain a healthy skepticism about revenue-generating opportunities. Recognize the pressure you may feel to generate income but carefully vet new possibilities and ask questions before getting involved.
“I’ve been surprised at how many physicians get involved in what I would consider sketchy revenue-generating opportunities without conducting any due diligence,” Ms. Valiant said. If you have concerns, seek guidance from trusted colleagues, your compliance team, specialty society, or an attorney experienced in healthcare law.
If something still doesn’t add up after you’ve asked questions and sought clarification, additional action may be warranted. That’s easier said than done. It can be difficult to know what to do—or whom to approach—in the moment. See “From Red Flag to Responsible Response” (below) for guidance on possible next steps.
And if you receive an audit request, take it seriously. Even if you’re certain your practice is 100% above board.
“One thing that happens a lot, especially in smaller practices, is that physicians view a request as a ‘routine audit,’” Ms. Valiant said. “Increasingly, there really aren’t routine audits; audits arise because someone complained or because they’re looking at your data and something looks odd.”
Notify your compliance officer or team promptly when an audit request arrives. Legal counsel may also be appropriate if the request comes from a government agency or enforcement body, involves a substantial number of claims or potential overpayment, alleges misconduct, or reveals concerns about billing or documentation.
Work with these advisers to understand the scope of the request and provide complete, accurate information that addresses the questions underlying the audit.
“They’ll ask for the medical record, but what they’re often really asking you to do is justify what you billed,” Ms. Valiant said. “You’ve got to look at it from that standpoint and provide everything you think is going to be a justification.”
If, while pulling together documentation, you (or your billing team) realize that some potentially helpful records are missing, do not amend the record without following the proper channels.
“Don’t fabricate any documentation; folks in this specialty have gotten dinged for fabricating documentation,” Ms. Valiant said. “You can supplement what’s there as long as you clearly indicate that it’s a later entry or explanation.”
Healthcare fraud will likely remain something most otolaryngologists encounter only in headlines. But every ENT practice is affected by the consequences of fraud. Careful billing, thorough documentation, and a willingness to ask questions can help protect patients, physicians, and the specialty as a whole.
Jennifer Fink is a freelance medical writer based in Wisconsin.
From Red Flag to Responsible Response
We’ve all heard the adage “If you see something, say something.” But potential fraud or misconduct is not always clear-cut, and deciding how (and to whom) to raise a concern can be challenging. If something doesn’t add up, these steps—drawn from advice from physicians, a healthcare-fraud attorney, and the American Medical Association—can help:
Avoid premature conclusions. “There may be perfectly good explanations for documentation discrepancies and unusual billing patterns. Don’t ignore your concerns, but don’t assume ill intent either,” said Peter Manes, MD, associate professor of surgery (otolaryngology) at Yale School of Medicine. If you have a good relationship with your colleagues, review the relevant records, practice patterns, and billing documentation together. “This need not be accusatory or punitive,” Dr. Manes said. “This may be an opportunity for education.”
Seek input from a trusted mentor. “If you’re in doubt about what to do, seek counsel from a colleague or mentor in the professional community who can help you think through your concerns,” said G. Richard Holt, MD, D Bioethics, professor emeritus of otolaryngology– head and neck surgery at the University of Texas San Antonio School of Medicine.
Talk to your compliance officer or team. If questions or concerns remain after a good-faith effort to address irregularities, consult your practice’s compliance officer, team, or designated contact. (In a smaller practice, that may be a practice administrator, billing manager, physician–owner, or outside compliance adviser.)
Consult a healthcare attorney when appropriate. Legal duties and reporting protections vary by state. An attorney with experience in healthcare compliance or medical board matters can help you understand your obligations and options.
Report concerning conduct to the appropriate clinical authorities. The AMA advises physicians who “strongly suspect” conduct that threatens patient safety or violates ethical and legal standards to notify the peer review body of the appropriate hospitals (AMA. https://tinyurl.com/22rfx4ts).
Report directly to the state licensing board when the conduct in question poses an immediate threat to the health and safety of patients (or violates state licensing provisions) (AMA. https://tinyurl.com/22rfx4ts).

Leave a Reply