ENTtoday
  • Home
  • Practice Focus
    • Allergy
    • Facial Plastic/Reconstructive
    • Head and Neck
    • Laryngology
    • Otology/Neurotology
    • Pediatric
    • Rhinology
    • Sleep Medicine
  • Departments
    • Issue Archive
    • TRIO Best Practices
      • Allergy
      • Facial Plastic/Reconstructive
      • Head and Neck
      • Laryngology
      • Otology/Neurotology
      • Pediatric
      • Rhinology
      • Sleep Medicine
    • Career Development
    • Case of the Month
    • Everyday Ethics
    • Health Policy
    • Legal Matters
    • Letter From the Editor
    • Medical Education
    • Online Exclusives
    • Practice Management
    • Resident Focus
    • Rx: Wellness
    • Special Reports
    • Tech Talk
    • Viewpoint
    • What’s Your O.R. Playlist?
  • Literature Reviews
    • Allergy
    • Facial Plastic/Reconstructive
    • Head and Neck
    • Laryngology
    • Otology/Neurotology
    • Pediatric
    • Rhinology
    • Sleep Medicine
  • Events
    • Featured Events
    • TRIO Meetings
  • Contact Us
    • About Us
    • Editorial Board
    • Triological Society
    • Advertising Staff
    • Subscribe
  • Advertise
    • Place an Ad
    • Classifieds
    • Rate Card
  • Search

Reliance on Exam Scores in Residency Applicant Selection Restricts Diversity in Otolaryngology

by Linda Kossoff • November 18, 2021

  • Tweet
  • Email
Print-Friendly Version

Does strict use of United States Medical Licensing Examination (USMLE) otolaryngology scores in residency applicant selection lead to a restriction in diversity?

BOTTOM LINE

You Might Also Like

No related posts.

Explore This Issue
November 2021

Strict adherence to USMLE scores may lead to disproportionally low recruitment of applicants who are female, >30 years of age, underrepresented minorities, and from institutions without an otolaryngology residency program.

COMMENT: Despite its intended purpose, the Step 1 component has taken on an alternate role. Residency programs have increasingly used this score during the screening stage to reduce the number of applications undergoing more in-depth review. Beginning on January 26, 2022, examinees who take Step 1 will receive only a notification of Pass or Fail rather than the standard threedigit score. The otolaryngology community has expressed apprehension about the scoring change and the likely substitution of Step 2 as a screening metric. Many of the currently underrepresented groups in otolaryngology would continue to be at a disadvantage if overemphasis on Step 2 were to develop. This presents an opportunity to prepare for this change, including a reassessment of screening metrics, and hasten the transition to holistic review. —Sarah N. Bowe, MD

 

 

BACKGROUND: Many residency selection committees among competitive specialties use the USMLE Step 1 score to filter applicant pools vying for limited residency positions. This may effectively reduce diversity based on gender, age, and distribution of underrepresented minorities (URMs). Otolaryngology lags behind other medical specialties in URM and female representation.

STUDY DESIGN: Cross-sectional study.

SETTING: Department of Otolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery, University of California, Davis, Sacramento, Calif.

SYNOPSIS: Researchers analyzed 381 2019-2020 otolaryngology residency applicants to a single institution. Among applicants, 37% were women; 9% were >30 years of age; 12% were URMs; 71% to 81% had above-average socioeconomic surrogate markers; 22% were from a top-ranked institution; 81% were from an institution with an otolaryngology residency program; and 92% were U.S. allopathic medical school graduates. Most self-identified as Caucasian (50.5%), followed by Asian (29.6%), Hispanic/Latino (6.3%), African American/ Black (5.8%), and Native Hawaiian/ Pacific Islander (0.5%). Authors note the disparity between the U.S. population percentages of URMs and medical school graduates identified as such. The proportion of female otolaryngology applicants was low despite the increased numbers of women matriculating into medical school. Older and URM applicants had lower USMLE Step 1 and 2 scores than their counterparts; women’s Step 1 scores were slightly lower than men’s. However, noting the lack of an established link between USMLE Step 1 score and resident performance, authors suggest that as Step 1 moves to pass/fail, otolaryngology residency selection committees take preventative measures to avert an unwarranted overemphasis of Step 2 scores. Study limitations included reliance on self-reported variables among subjects.

Pages: 1 2 | Single Page

Filed Under: Diversity, Literature Reviews Tagged With: career development, diversity, otolaryngologyIssue: November 2021

You Might Also Like:

The Triological SocietyENTtoday is a publication of The Triological Society.

The Laryngoscope
Ensure you have all the latest research at your fingertips; Subscribe to The Laryngoscope today!

Laryngoscope Investigative Otolaryngology
Open access journal in otolaryngology – head and neck surgery is currently accepting submissions.

Classifieds

View the classified ads »

TRIO Best Practices

View the TRIO Best Practices »

Top Articles for Residents

  • Do Training Programs Give Otolaryngology Residents the Necessary Tools to Do Productive Research?
  • Why More MDs, Medical Residents Are Choosing to Pursue Additional Academic Degrees
  • What Physicians Need to Know about Investing Before Hiring a Financial Advisor
  • Tips to Help You Regain Your Sense of Self
  • Should USMLE Step 1 Change from Numeric Score to Pass/Fail?
  • Popular this Week
  • Most Popular
  • Most Recent
    • The Dramatic Rise in Tongue Tie and Lip Tie Treatment
    • Second Victims: The Effects of a Medical Error on Physicians Can Be Devastating
    • Advanced Degrees Can Help Otolaryngologists Better Understand the Business of Medicine
    • How to: A Dynamic Endonasal Columellar Strut Placement
    • Rating Laryngopharyngeal Reflux Severity: How Do Two Common Instruments Compare?
    • The Dramatic Rise in Tongue Tie and Lip Tie Treatment
    • Rating Laryngopharyngeal Reflux Severity: How Do Two Common Instruments Compare?
    • Vertigo in the Elderly: What Does It Mean?
    • What Happens to Medical Students Who Don’t Match?
    • Complications for When Physicians Change a Maiden Name
    • Qualitative Research Shows How Patients Feel About Quality-of-Life Issues
    • How to: A Dynamic Endonasal Columellar Strut Placement
    • Second Victims: The Effects of a Medical Error on Physicians Can Be Devastating
    • Advanced Degrees Can Help Otolaryngologists Better Understand the Business of Medicine
    • Laser Laryngeal Surgery Is Safe Under THRIVE

Polls

Have you ever been, or have you ever known someone who has been a second victim?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
  • Polls Archive
  • Home
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookie Preferences

Visit: The Triological Society • The Laryngoscope • Laryngoscope Investigative Otolaryngology

Wiley
© 2023 The Triological Society. All Rights Reserved.
ISSN 1559-4939